Menu

Product & UX Second Opinion

Challenge a specific product, design or research decision by independently reviewing the supplied work and supporting evidence.

Fixed Price

£2,495excluding VATor PAYG

VAT is added where applicable. Tax treatment depends on your location and business status, not your chosen currency.

Designed for

  • One product, service or strategic decision
  • Existing research, designs or documentation
  • Independent expert review
  • Senior UX, research and product advice
  • 1–2 weeks delivery

Need something different? The proposal confirms the journeys, screens, content or source material to review and the assessment depth before commissioning. Larger or more complex scopes are quoted separately. Get in touch.

How do I know if my project is the right fit? ↓

What a product and UX second opinion covers

Sometimes confidence is the most valuable deliverable.

A Product & UX Second Opinion gives you an independent, experienced perspective before making an important product, design or UX decision.

Whether you’re reviewing an existing product, preparing for a redesign, evaluating research or questioning the direction of a project, the review pressure-tests the decision and provides objective feedback based on user-centred design principles and practical delivery experience.

The goal isn’t to replace your team’s expertise. It’s to provide reassurance, challenge assumptions and help you move forward with greater confidence.

Choose this review when a specific decision needs independent challenge: whether to accept an agency recommendation, proceed with a redesign or act on a research conclusion. The assessment examines the supplied work and evidence in relation to that decision. It is not a substitute for a broad Live Product UX Audit or a detailed Pre-build UX Design Review.

Common problems

01

You’re not completely convinced by the current direction

An independent perspective can highlight risks before important decisions are made.

02

Stakeholders have different opinions

Objective feedback helps teams align around evidence rather than assumptions.

03

A significant investment is about to be made

Validate the direction before committing more time, budget or resources.

04

You simply want reassurance

Sometimes an experienced second opinion is enough to confirm you’re on the right track.

Why work with me

Sometimes confidence is the most valuable deliverable.

Sometimes the most valuable thing an experienced consultant can do isn’t redesign a product or run another piece of research.

It’s to ask the questions nobody else is asking.

A second opinion provides independent, objective feedback based on experience gained across hundreds of digital products, services and delivery teams. Rather than becoming part of the project, I step back, assess the situation and help you understand whether you’re solving the right problem in the right way.

The result is greater confidence, clearer thinking and better-informed decisions before significant investment takes place.

Is this right for you?

What you’ll receive

01

Kick-off session

A discussion to understand your product, challenges and the decisions you’re trying to make.

02

Independent review

Objective assessment of your product, designs, research or strategy.

03

Prioritised observations

Practical feedback highlighting strengths, risks and opportunities.

04

Recommendations

Clear advice explaining what I’d change, what I’d keep and why.

05

Playback session

A collaborative discussion of the findings with time for questions.

06

Written summary

A concise document capturing recommendations and suggested next steps.

What’s not included

  • User research
  • Product redesign
  • Visual design production
  • Development support
  • Ongoing consultancy

Example deliverables

01

Second Opinion report

An independent assessment of your product, designs or strategy.

02

Prioritised recommendations

Practical advice explaining where improvements should be focused.

03

Executive summary

A concise overview for stakeholders and decision makers.

04

Prioritised action plan

A prioritised list of suggested next steps.

Typical timeline

1–2 weeks

Timelines run from the agreed start date, once required access and materials are available. Delivery can vary with scope, complexity, participant availability and feedback. Expedited delivery may be available at an additional cost, subject to scope and availability.

Week 1

Kick-off and review

Review the existing work, supporting evidence and project context.

Weeks 1–2

Playback and recommendations

Present findings, answer questions and discuss next steps.

Frequently Asked Questions

How is this different from a Pre-build UX Design Review or Live Product UX Audit?

A Product & UX Second Opinion is organised around a decision and the evidence supporting it. A Pre-build UX Design Review examines a proposed experience before development. A Live Product UX Audit examines usability across agreed journeys in a working product. Agreeing the decision and material to assess keeps the Product & UX Second Opinion focused.

What kinds of projects is this designed for?

Every Product & UX Second Opinion is designed to help you make important product, UX or research decisions with greater confidence.

Typical examples include:

  • A product or service about to enter development.
  • Existing UX work that would benefit from an independent review.
  • A strategic product decision with differing stakeholder opinions.
  • Research findings that need challenging or validating.
  • A leadership team looking for an experienced external perspective.

Larger or more complex projects are usually better suited to a bespoke engagement.

When should I ask for a second opinion?

The best time is before making an important product, UX or research decision where an independent perspective could reduce risk or improve confidence.

Can you review work completed by another agency?

Yes.

The review is completely independent and focuses on helping your organisation make better decisions, regardless of who produced the original work.

Will you simply confirm what we’ve already decided?

Not necessarily.

If I believe another approach would better support your users or business goals, I’ll explain why and provide practical recommendations based on the evidence available.

Where are you based?

I’m based in Manchester, UK and work with organisations across the UK, Europe and internationally. Most projects are delivered remotely, although I’m happy to travel for workshops, stakeholder sessions and key project milestones where required.

Do you work remotely?

Yes. Most projects are delivered remotely using Microsoft Teams, Google Meet or Zoom. Working remotely allows me to support organisations across the UK and internationally while remaining flexible and cost-effective.

Will I work directly with you?

Yes. Every project is delivered by me. If additional specialist support is ever needed, I’ll discuss it with you first, but you’ll always work directly with me throughout the project.

Can you work alongside our existing team?

Absolutely. Many clients already have designers, researchers, developers or product managers in place. I can provide additional capacity, independent advice or senior support without disrupting the way your team already works.

Do you only work with large organisations?

No. I’ve worked with startups, SMEs, agencies, charities, public sector organisations and global enterprises. Every engagement is tailored to the size, complexity and goals of the organisation.

What if my project doesn’t fit one of your fixed engagements?

The fixed engagements are designed around the most common types of engagement. If your project requires something different, I’ll create a bespoke proposal based on your goals, timescales and scope.

How quickly can you start?

Availability varies throughout the year, but many fixed engagements can begin within one to two weeks. If you have an urgent requirement, let me know and I’ll always do my best to accommodate it.

Do you sign NDAs and work with confidential information?

Yes. Much of my work has involved commercially sensitive products, government services and confidential research. I’m happy to sign NDAs and regularly work with organisations where confidentiality is essential.

LET'S WORK TOGETHER

Ready to improve your product?

UX, research and product leadership for teams tackling complex digital services.

Previous feedback

I had a fantastic experience working with Andy. One of his most impressive achievements during our time at NHS HEE was masterminding a deeply complex information architecture for a new platform that brought together a large number of legacy websites.

Will Parkhouse

Senior Content Designer

If you’d value an experienced, independent perspective before making an important product or design decision, let’s discuss whether a Product & UX Second Opinion is the right place to start.

Cookies

With your permission, Google Analytics uses cookies to measure visits and how this website is used. Advertising cookies stay off.

Before you choose, and if you reject cookies, Google receives cookieless measurement signals.

Your choice is remembered for six months. You can change it here at any time.